First off, I love the packaging of these products! The boxes they come in are really pretty. This might not seem important, but I like beauty products that come in pretty boxes.
These are all good products, but I like the Color Quench Lip Tint the best of the three, probably because that's the type of product I usually like the best of these types. My lips tend to dry out at work, so I have it at my desk and have been using it daily. I really like products like this, which are lightweight and natural with just a hint of color, for everyday wear.